One of the most common questions we hear is: “Why did this product work for my friend’s horse but not mine?” The truth is, just like people, horses are individuals. Their bodies, routines, and environments all play a role in how they respond to the same care product.

It’s Just Like People

Think about it—two people can eat the same meal, and one walks away happy while the other gets an upset stomach. Sometimes we even blame the food for making us sick, when in reality it may have been stress, timing, or something unrelated. Horses are no different. A product might be blamed for an issue, when the real cause is something else entirely.

Factors That Influence a Horse’s Reaction

• Age & Metabolism: Young horses process ingredients differently than older ones, just like youthful athletes recover faster than seniors.
• Health History: A horse with previous injuries or sensitivities may respond differently than one without.
• Environment: Weather, humidity, dust, and even stall conditions affect how products interact with skin and muscle.
• Application & Handling: The way a product is applied—before work, after work, under wraps, or left on—can dramatically change the outcome.
• Expectations: If you expect immediate results but the product is designed for consistent, long-term support, it might feel like it “didn’t work.”

Why This Matters

When you hear a negative story about a product, remember: it’s one horse, one environment, one situation. That doesn’t mean it will be the same for you. In fact, most products earn loyal followings because the majority of riders do see consistent, positive results.

Judge for Yourself

At Draw It Out®, we encourage riders to trust their own firsthand experience. No two horses are exactly alike, and the best way to know if something works is to test it in your barn, on your routine, with your horse. That’s the kind of judgment we stand behind.

Bottom line: Don’t let someone else’s horse—or someone else’s story—decide for you. Trust your own experience and your horse’s response. Because at the end of the day, your judgment is what matters most.